American Idol Made History by Bringing Carrie Underwood in as a Judge, But Social Media Is in Chaos

Carrie Underwood makes history as the first-ever “American Idol” winner to become a judge, debuting in season 23. Joining Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, Underwood replaces Katy Perry, who left the show to focus on music and travel.

While some fans miss Perry, many are already praising Underwood’s compassionate and supportive judging style. Despite the change, Underwood has received praise from fans for her sincerity and connection to contestants, with some calling her one of the greatest judges in the show’s history.